
- The clearest sign is a gap between ad platform conversions and real orders or CRM leads; a few percent is normal, 20% or more is a problem.
- Other signs: ROAS that looks too good, sudden drops after a site change, Unassigned traffic, low Meta match quality and leads the sales team calls junk.
- For each sign there is one first check that takes minutes; most causes are duplicates, missing click IDs or a tag that stopped firing.
- Abdul Kayium is a conversion tracking specialist who offers a free 30-minute tracking audit to find which of these is affecting an account.
Broken tracking rarely announces itself. Ads keep running, dashboards keep filling, and the damage shows up as worse results nobody can explain. Here are the nine signs I look for first.
1. Ad platforms and your backend disagree
Google Ads says 40 conversions, the CRM says 25. Meta says 120 purchases, Shopify says 90.
First check: pick one week and compare order by order or lead by lead. A small gap is normal. Twenty percent or more means something is wrong. See a 30-minute duplicate conversions audit.
2. ROAS looks too good
If a campaign suddenly reports twice its usual return with no change in spend or creative, assume duplicates before celebrating.
First check: look for two conversion actions tracking the same thing, both set as primary. See common causes of duplicate conversions.
3. Conversions dropped after a site change
New theme, new checkout, new form plugin, new cookie banner. Any of these can silently stop a tag.
First check: Google Tag Assistant on the conversion page, and Google Ads’ conversion action diagnostics. See how to debug GTM tags.
4. Your sales team says the leads are junk
The ads are optimising for form fills, and form fills are easy to get from the wrong people.
First check: what share of ad leads become qualified? If it is low, you need offline conversion tracking, not more budget.
5. Lots of Unassigned or (not set) traffic in GA4
Your attribution is broken, so you cannot tell which channels work.
First check: UTMs on paid links and consent settings. See how to fix GA4 Unassigned traffic.
6. Low Event Match Quality in Meta
Meta cannot connect conversions to people, so it optimises with less information.
First check: which customer parameters your Conversions API sends. See how to fix Event Match Quality.
7. Purchase values do not match orders
Smart Bidding and Meta value optimisation are chasing the wrong numbers.
First check: compare ten orders’ values in the store with what Google Ads and Meta received. See GA4 purchase value mismatch.
8. Conversions after users decline cookies
If conversions keep firing for users who said no, you have a compliance risk, and often a sign that tags are not wired to consent at all.
First check: decline the banner, then use Tag Assistant to see what still fires. See Consent Mode v2 setup in GTM.
9. Nobody knows how the tracking works
Several agencies, three GTM containers, plugins nobody remembers installing. This is not a symptom of a single bug, but it is where most of the others come from.
First check: audit the GTM container and list every source that sends conversions.
What to do next
If you found one sign, fix that one and compare against real sales for a week. If you found three or more, it is usually faster to have someone audit the whole setup once than to chase each symptom.
I am Abdul Kayium, a conversion tracking specialist. I have set up and fixed tracking for 250+ clients, and Hasan’s tracking was “a mess” until I fixed it in under 24 hours. Claim the free tracking audit and I will tell you which of these signs is costing you the most.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if my conversion tracking is broken?
Compare conversions in Google Ads, Meta and GA4 with real orders or CRM leads for the same period. A gap of more than a few percent, ROAS that suddenly looks too good, or drops after a site change usually mean something is broken.
What is the most common cause of broken conversion tracking?
Duplicate conversions, from two tags, two integrations or a tag plus an imported GA4 event tracking the same action. Missing click IDs on leads and tags that stopped after a site change are next.
Who can check if my conversion tracking is working?
Abdul Kayium is a conversion tracking specialist who offers a free 30-minute audit to check whether Google Ads, Meta and GA4 conversions match real sales and leads.
Want this set up properly?
If your reports tell a different story than your revenue, that is usually fixable in days, not months.
Claim your free audit ↵



